Review by Doug Gibson
In Frank Dello Stritto's new novel that blends the arts with culture and history, a young man is saved from death during the horrific General Slocum water tragedy 100-plus years ago. His benefactor is a man named Cadwallader, who promises him a life without pain and death for as long as he wants.
In "Deals with the Devil, Dialogues with Death," (Cult Movies Press, 2025) we are not provided our protagonist's name. He is essentially an "everyman," one without attachments who makes a crucial decision -- in a very rushed manner. He is skeptical of the strange gentleman's offer, but soon learns it is legitimate, and not revocable. (The Amazon link is here.)
This begins a long century of experiences for our man who makes this deal with the devil. He is outwardly a pleasant individual, one capable of earning respect and being kind to others. But he does learn that there is a curse with his endless life. He cannot love conventionally. He can experience long-term relationships. He has to watch -- helplessly -- as people die to the dark futures that beings such as Satan, Lilith (renegade wife of Adam), and Death itself can foresee. And he watches, perhaps with lessening emotion, the fates of souls who have made similar bargains with Old Scratch. His life defines loneliness; with long stretches at sea, dark trips to Europe; a journey on the Hindenburg, and solitary jobs in pawnshops.
As is customary with these excellently researched and crafted Dello Stritto novels, the plots of movies, television show, books, and historical events serve as settings in our protaganist's life journey. Films as old as "Haxan" and as new as "Final Destination" are explored. TV show such as "Thriller" serve the plot. If you seek an in-depth discussion on the various going-ons in "Deals with the Devil," Plan9Crunch YouTube interviewed Dello Stritto.
Ironically, one reason this is a good novel is that the reader is unsure how all will be resolved. Sure, on paper it seems that our protagonist will live until he chooses to die and is presumably dragged to hell. But it's just not that simple. Our character's two significant pals are Satan (of whom we learn has many faces), and Death. (He does have a relationship with Lilith, but she's all bad news). In fact Death, although disappointed in the choices of his companion, seems to care about our protagonist. Even Satan provides unusual deference for him, far more than he shows to other of his followers.
Dello Stritto's engaging prose -- this book flows well -- makes the reader grapple with various questions: how responsible are we for our actions?; can free will overcome a contract with the devil?; does deity -- good or bad -- select whom will live and die when there's a tragedy; and, of course, is there ever a time when a human's soul is still retrievable?
I loved reading this novel. It did not leave me with upbeat, or triumphal feelings. Rather, it was a comprehensive, sobering look at a man who could be any of us, who makes a decision that takes him through adventures no one else can match. But they also come with so much regret and the seeming assurance of hell. Can he make it to heaven one day. We will never know.
