Ranking The Main Deadites In Each Evil Dead Film

 

 

By Joe Gibson

 

Recently, to ring in the release of Evil Dead Burn, I have been rewatching some of the previous films with the goal of ranking the main Deadites in each film. Then, I figured it did not make much sense to exclude Burn from this list so I watched Evil Dead Burn, taking note of who can be considered the main Deadite, and this ranking will help me formulate my thoughts for my updated Evil Dead film ranking. Without much further ado, we will start this list with some controversial shenanigans. Major spoilers ahead for Evil Dead Burn.

 

#6 - Deadite Mia, Evil Dead 2013

 

This is a controversial placement because most people (correctly) view Mia to be an improvement over Cheryl, but allow me to explain why her Deadite version is this low despite being on par with or better than Cheryl’s. I feel it is a rather logical technicality. Deadite Mia comprises essentially 3 different characters, and the actual Deadite version of Mia that infects Olivia and Natalie that gets stuck in the cellar is leagues ahead of the two that this movie forces me to lump in with her. 

 

When the Naturom Demonto turns Mia, the scene uses imagery of a different Mia appearing to her, and this is very enigmatic to me. It happens again with Olivia later, but in that case Deadite Olivia acted in the same manner as the vision she had, which is not true of this first Deadite Mia that only screams and summons the vines for the obligatory rape scene. Perhaps, this being is the same as the third version of Deadite Mia, the Abomination that rises for the boss fight. But that doesn’t really make sense either. The Abomination still has yet to rise by that point, and I am assuming that the in-universe reason it chose Mia’s form was because she was far and away the most tenacious and long living of the Deadite options available to it, which she was not yet at the time of her corruption. (There is reason to believe that the Abomination itself returned in a different form in Evil Dead Burn, and that visage would also be contextual.) So three characters. 

 

And yes they all have to look like Mia in order to further the drug abuse metaphor where she battles the worst aspects of herself, but I will again point out how the film does not use that well, because she does not fight the Abomination in a manner coded as getting clean; she fights the Abomination in a way coded to the Deadites (and thus her addiction) in this movie: self mutilating (cutting off her hand) in order to hurt the people closest to her. Also, though my main consideration here is the main Deadite of the film, I have to consider the others, and 2013, aside from Deadite Mia 2, has the worst Deadite cast. They act essentially as zombies and because the Deadite possession was meant to symbolize Mia's drug addiction, the rest of the Deadites are superfluous to the movie, have nothing to contribute and each barely last a scene.

 

#5 - Bad Ash, Army of Darkness

 

Army of Darkness has the most wild variation of Deadites aside from maybe Evil Dead 2, as Deadite ranks consist of weird flying harpy things, a pit witch, a pit b–Deadite, an army of skeletons, a battalion of Mini Ashs, and the fearsome leader Bad Ash, the cellular mitosis result of Ash swallowing one of his tiny doppelgangers. For the nostalgic practical effects and the truly unique tone of this film, it is almost a tie between this and the number four spot. I appreciate both immensely.

 

The meat of this section will have to go to evaluating Bad Ash, but I probably have to justify why I am calling him that. The Bad Ash label is an inclusive umbrella term that can describe any time Ash gets Deadited, and even though the specific character in Army of Darkness calls himself Bad Ash, he is officially named Evil Ash. That is dumb. 

He is Bad Ash because he says he is, and I am more than happy to just call the Evil Dead 2 Deadite versions Deadite Ash 1 and Deadite Ash 2 (apparently Bad Ash himself was the doppelganger in the mirror in Evil Dead 2 though his vocal pitch was lower there). Whether or not we should count these as separate characters or the same is unclear because apparently in Ash vs Evil Dead, a version of Bad Ash called Evil Ash 2 grows out of Ash’s severed hand, and I have not yet ascertained if they are the same personality or even the same demon.

 

In the context of Army of Darkness, Ash kind of stumbles into hijacking both sides of a skeleton war, and while the real Ash grows into a (slightly) better hero, his evil doppelganger loses all semblance of humanity, eventually becoming just another skeleton (albeit the coolest looking one). Though Bad Ash shares several character traits with Ash, including attraction to Sheila, he overestimates the moral virtue of Ash consistently. Even after Ash shot him and cut him into pieces without hesitation, Bad Ash is still surprised when Ash stabs him in the back later during the castle siege. That is a more interesting Evil Clone dynamic than usually occurs in popular media. I can’t help but feel like Bad Ash holds the film back from being a little scarier, but the second they changed the title from Medieval Dead to (Bruce Campbell vs The) Army of Darkness, that was already a given.

 

Still, the bulk of the Deadite creativity went into Bad Ash’s various forms and choreography, which kind of grounds him into being a microcosm for the whole Deadite cast. At first, he mimics the impish nature of his diminutive progenitors, still resembling a human more than a corpse. After his burial, he is rotted to a sufficient degree to fit alongside the more detailed captains in his army, and, by the end, he is a stop motion skeleton like the bulk of his army. You will see this with the next pick on this list, but just because a film does not have the definitive Deadite does not mean I dislike them. With how experimental this series is, I will accept whatever episodic spin each film wants to put on their Deadites (so long as they do it more holistically than 2013 did).

 

#4 - Burning Deadite, Evil Dead Burn

 

Though I have claimed before and will continue to claim after this post that Burning Will is the main Deadite in Evil Dead Burn, this new film might be the closest to a true ensemble. Jessica acts like a classic Deadite to get the plot started, Edgar fits closest into the Cheryl role, though he, himself, technically could have been any creature including a vampire based on the way he acts, Thya and Polly both get major setpieces as main antagonist, and Susan is the most continuous antagonist to Alice in the film. 

 

Still, Will is the reason for the gathering, the reason for Edgar's infection, the pattern of behavior that the film uses Deadites to examine, and the other Deadites foretell of his coming similarly to 2013's Abomination (also it takes at least 5 souls claimed for him to finally show up). Also like that Abomination, Will has a burning touch and headlines a boss fight. If certain commentators are correct, then Jessica actually transferred her essence to Will, which would be another point of similarity to the Abomination. 

 

The Abomination, in the symbolism of 2013, is Mia finally facing and overcoming the darker aspects of her character, but in the actual narrative and plot, it's just a boss fight, and the Abomination is just fishing out around for stock dialogue, which would be the case for Jessica if the Burning Deadite is not just a new one made from giving a new demon Will's memories. (Yes, I know that Polly implies that she wants to take that passerby's leg in the post credits scene, but that does not inherently mean she wants to body hop. I would expect a Deadite that's down a leg to rip off a human's and try to animate it before I would expect the masochistic self harming Deadites to jump ship once the body is arbitrarily too damaged.) 

 

My ideal Deadites would look more like Cheryl, Ed, Henrietta or even Mia with the more uncanny deterioration, but within this film making it very difficult to differentiate the personality of Edgar and his Deadite, I would prefer people's demons remain their own. Also, given the variety of the Deadites on display, with a dog, a fire demon, and a funny Grandma, I can handle Edgar, Susan and Joseph’s lack of Deadite skin texture.

 

#3 - Deadite Cheryl, The Evil Dead

 

Though the film is very low budget, the progressing make up for the original Deadites, especially Cheryl, just conveys the body horror best of all for me. It is not enough to have the personality change into a sarcastic zombie with CGI effects; it is scary to see what Cheryl becomes over the course of her movie as the lead Deadite. (Even a top tier Deadite like Ellie feels a little naked without such a dramatic change to the skin texture in the face as what happens to Cheryl and Mia.) It is also scary to see it continue to happen to Shelly, Linda and Scotty, but, in retrospect, the better Deadite casts have a bit more variety and purpose to their transformations. 

 

As I mentioned in my Out of the Theater reaction to Evil Dead Burn, Scotty’s (and his emerging archetype) Deadite transformation is kind of superfluous most of the time. Shelly’s transformation is necessary to raise the stakes, but Linda ends up being the other standout Deadite of the film by acting differently than Cheryl in a way that gets to Ash. (It is tragic that Evil Dead 2013 struggled so much to give Natalie any kind of characterization living or dead-ite.)

 

There was clearly room for improvement in the makeup, but, as is the case with practical effects, it is real. It is something you can touch. We’re all playing along when we watch a movie, but you take that design and film it the right way and it is scary. I stand by my take that The Evil Dead is the true masterpiece of the franchise, but it also does not mean that its Deadites are untouchable. For instance, Scream 1996 is the best in that series, but I think the killers of films 2 and 4 are better.

 

#2 - The Marauder, Evil Dead Rise

 

I am closing out this ranking with some more shenanigans, though again I hope logically sound ones. While Deadite Ellie is the Cheryl of this movie, the fact that she participates in the boss fight as a fusion with the two other main Deadites of her film places more importance on the part of The Marauder. The Marauder proves my point of “The Main Deadite must be partially evaluated through the rest of the Deadite cast,” as it is the culmination of Deadite Ellie’s bizarre views of motherhood, thus becoming the obstacle for Beth to overcome on her journey to becoming a good mother. The beings that make up The Marauder also act like classic Deadites, a good return to form after 2013, with their eye shades representing the different types in the franchise and their taunts including the phrase “Dead by dawn”. However, part of Sam Raimi’s creativity with the Deadites was the sheer malleability that the Kandarian demon found in its prey, the asymmetry of the Evil Dead 2 Deadites and the fact that the tree was technically the boss fight there. The Marauder is a fine compromise to get us back to these "biologically impossible Deadite abominations.”

 

Now, Deadite Ellie herself is a standout in this franchise, and the conversation of the best Deadite in general will come down to Ellie or Henrietta (though Cheryl and Mia are often runnersup, and Jessica has some upward momentum if she is still around). I have held strong in my respect for Ted Raimi’s Henrietta, partially because Henrietta is the particular Deadite that always scared the crap out of me when I was younger. As you can tell, I am giving Henrietta the top spot today, but with the return of Ellie Bixler in the post credits scene of Evil Dead Burn, it seems clear that the franchise is not done with her. If Ellie is in the next film after Evil Dead Wrath, unless they severely botch her character, she will probably leave Henrietta far in the dust. I will give Henrietta her dues for now, but first, let us glaze Deadite Ellie.

 

Ellie, in some ways, feels like an amalgamation of the best parts of Cheryl and Henrietta: inciting Deadite made from the protagonist’s sister and creepy mother that sings a lullaby to her child. She is shut out (though in a hallway and not a cellar), and, when the plot has fully thickened, you get the classic moment of her cackling and frothing like a wild animal. Still, Ellie has her own unique accolades too. Alyssa Sutherland gives perhaps the greatest Deadite performance ever, with the optimal physicality and emotional range. The tension between the two Bixler sisters serves into the theme of the movie for once and also functions better, setting up the main conflict for Beth and remaining relevant through each plot point. (The throughline with David and Mia in 2013 is better than I had remembered actually, with him refusing to leave her behind, but human Mia’s lack of act 2 focus and David’s abrupt death still limit their dynamic.) 

 

Of the main Deadites in the franchise, it makes the most sense to bring her back, and even the method of bringing her back was not too strange for this franchise. Her urn in Evil Dead Burn was very small and likely only contains the arm and leg that Beth shot off in the hallway (the other Deadites there either left intact, fell dormant, both, like Jessica, or joined the rest of Ellie in the Marauder so only those limbs would be left intact amongst the carnage), and her tattoos make those limbs easily identifiable. Apparently, in Ash vs Evil Dead, Ash’s severed hand from Evil Dead 2 grew into a full second Bad Ash, so there is precedent for a Deadite limb to reassemble into the clone of a full Deadite. Like it or hate it, but Ellie 2 makes sense, so we will have to see how they utilize her in the future and if they take inspiration from the best Deadite.

 

#1 - Henrietta, Evil Dead 2

 

 

My recent rewatch has been most favorable to Evil Dead 2 as it resolved many of my issues with it, and I was once more taken aback by the tenacity of the Kandarian demon and its impressive Deadite cast. It is easy to forget how persistent the demon is trying to get Ash because Bobby Joe, Jake and Annie all remain human instead of turning into Deadites, but the demon tries every single trick it can to get Ash, turning him into a Deadite three times (if you count the hand) and literally chasing him throughout the cabin in its noncorporeal state. Deadite Linda is better here than in the first film (though I still do think her human form is underwritten except for the foreshadowing of the Deadite choreography with her dancing), and Ash’s hand is so unbelievably persistent compared to the entire cast of 2013. Ed, though again underwritten as a character, shines as a Deadite for his scene because of the uncanny facial prosthetics, and it is much cooler to see the Tree fight Ash than it is to see it rape somebody (but unfortunately it still does that as well.)

 

All of that is important and helps cement Evil Dead 2 as the most creative film in the franchise, but with the tone balancing at play here, Henrietta, despite her lack of screentime, actually almost singlehandedly is the thing keeping it a horror film. From her first appearance, she is a desiccated late stage Deadite with such mastery over her abilities that she is basically a shapeshifting witch. Though Ted Raimi plays her as a stunt casting with his tongue in his cheek, that makes her scarier, and the constant reminders that she is down in the cellar help to reset the tone when it gets too goofy. Consequently, Henrietta kind of slouches into the role of quintessential Deadite because she is incredibly powerful and scary but has such a potent sense of humor that she feels at home alongside Ash’s slapstick. I genuinely believe that Henrietta would feel just as much at home in The Evil Dead and Army of Darkness as in Evil Dead 2, and if you don’t believe that, why not? Henrietta has a range that no other Deadite before Ellie really had, and Henrietta still has an edge over her in that regard.

 

I avoided spoilers for Evil Dead Burn quite well ahead of the release. It was only while sitting in the theater during the previews that I stumbled upon the vague spoiler that the second post credits scene would feature the return of a Deadite that can be referred to as “Mommy.” Though I knew that probably meant Ellie was the one coming back, I held out hope it would be Henrietta because if we’re not getting Ash back, Henrietta is the next best thing. As you know, Ellie is back, but with that revelation comes implications for the rest of the franchise.

 

Bringing Ellie back without Beth and Kassie would be kind of hollow, so they and their chainsaw will probably be back as well. (Conversely, Henrietta is less tethered to her family at this point and probably actually knew the Prices, so could bounce off Polly well for comedic scenes.) Ellie, at this point, probably cannot manipulate either of them as well as she could initially, so they will need to find another angle with her, and I honestly think they should draw from Henrietta’s powerset. A flying shapeshifting Deadite witch would be a stakes escalation for both Beth and Alice, and I think it would be interesting if Alice, while presumably fending off Deadite possession like Ash in Evil Dead 2, hears Ellie in her deaf ear cracking dumb jokes. Alternatively, they could draw from Bad Ash, since Ellie also just materialized out of nowhere to presumably lead this growing Army of Darkness in the modern day. Whatever they chose to do with Ellie, it is important to note that the filmmakers now finally have a chance to surpass Henrietta, and they had better not squander it whatever direction they go in.

Here at Plan9Crunch we like the Evil Dead films (though our tastes are slightly different between each of us), and we have covered some of them in the past here and have plans for further coverage. Our YouTube page as an "Out of The Theater" reaction to Evil Dead Burn, and there will be a longer review in a couple of weeks. Also, around that time, I will release an updated ranking of the films including Evil Dead Burn here.