By JOSEPH GIBSON
The
following essay was presented at the 2024 National Undergraduate Literature
Conference at Weber State.
Abstract
- 439 words
In the 1969 giant monster movie Gamera vs
Guiron from Daiei Film, two curious boys embark on an interplanetary
adventure. Seeking a more advanced world, they come into conflict with
its sole survivors, forcing a three round monster brawl between the boys’
friend, a giant turtle named Gamera, and the aliens’ watchdog, a quadrupedal
fish with a knife for a head called Guiron (Yuasa, 1969). Fans of the
series praise this film in a backhanded sense, acknowledging lessened quality
while upholding what it “tried” to do (Madole, 2022). This essay argues that Gamera
vs Guiron uniquely explores psychological concepts proposed by Carl Jung,
as opposed to more traditional themes for its technical subgenre of portal
fantasy. The ways in which the film develops its primary monsters,
characters and worlds most strongly portray several Jungian ideas such as the
self, shadow, anima, unconscious world and “answer to Job.”
Out of the twelve Gamera movies, Gamera vs
Guiron is the fifth installment and the fourth of director Noriaki
Yuasa. AIP, an American production company Daiei partnered with for
distribution, ordered Gamera vs Guiron to be a straightforward space adventure
(Draper, 2023). However, the crew’s input resulted in a script that
follows plot beats of portal fantasy while containing events that benefit from
a Jungian analysis. Nisan Takahashi wrote all of the early Gamera films,
Hidemasa Nagata, producer, enforced the films as fairy tale lessons for
children, and Yuasa defined Gamera’s identity as a character and series through
a reciprocal connection to active and curious child protagonists (Cynical
Justin, 2022). Meanwhile, Dr. Carl Gustav Jung, Swiss psychoanalyst and
contemporary to Freud, wrote prolifically on the collective unconsciousness,
naming archetypes as patterns of behavior (Jung & Stoor, 2013, pp.
13-16). The persona, anima/animus and shadow count as archetypes of the
self and personal unconscious, and the collective unconscious archetypes are
the creator, ruler, caregiver, everyman, jester, lover, hero, magician, rebel,
explorer, sage, and innocent (Main, 2023). Being a Japanese children’s film, it
is certainly an unlikely place to find demonstrations of the archetypes of Carl
Jung; Jung’s ideas have uniquely informed the landscape of cinema. Jung’s
insights into the self and shadow or anima and animus dichotomies have shaped
the cinematic trope of doubles (Barnett, 2007). At the conclusion of this
essay, the implementation of information from sources ranging from compilations
of Jung’s work to scholarly articles analyzing Jung as well as portal fantasy
conventions will indicate similarities to a Jungian perspective. Because
of the juxtaposition of these heretofore unconnected concepts, the findings in
this essay will contribute to academic discourse on Japanese B movies and the
men and philosophies that made them.
Jungian
Shadow And Christ Concepts - 645 words
The rivalry between Gamera and Guiron is uniquely
Jungian in that Guiron serves as Gamera’s Shadow. Generally, Jung writes
on the idea of the shadow as being undesirable unconscious facets of the hero
that keep them from a true understanding of themselves and their world (Jung
& Stoor, pp. 91-93). While analyzing
Nietzche’s Zarathustra, Jung clarified that the shadow is a negative
relationship between archetypes, informed by insecurities or possible failings
(Jung, 2012). Gamera does not fit any of the 12 common literary
archetypes, so for this stage of the analysis, Gamera is Gamera, Guiron as an
inverse Gamera. On the surface, the knife head of Guiron contrasts
Gamera’s protective shell, casting Guiron merely as the aggressor to Gamera’s
defender, the sword against his shield in the theaters of land, sky and
underwater. However, Guiron’s introduction into the film is defending the other
world Tera from Gyaos, a monster that Gamera defended Earth from.
Furthermore, Guiron has a connection to the two remaining Terans, Flobella and
Barbella, just as Gamera protects Akio and Tom specifically.
Additionally, the film chooses a gray and red/orange color palette for Tera
that it keeps consistent with the infrastructure as well as the new Teran breed
of Gyaos, indicating that the gray, red and green Guiron, since Gamera is also
green, is to be Tera’s Gamera. (Yuasa, 1969).
Gamera is a being that inexplicably knows the state of the
universe and the needs of his human friends, what they should do, and how he
can help them, with no internal change necessary, which can only make him,
according to Jungian psychological archetypes, the ideal Self: the
Christ. If the premise of attributing a turtle with human psychological
qualities seems unwise, according to a 2002 interview with Jörg Buttgereit, Noriaki Yuasa’s understanding
of the giant monster subgenre was thus that animals and humans were very
similar in the capacity and expression of certain feelings (2002). Gamera undeniably serves a mentor role to the
children, warning them against going to Tera and fighting to his utmost to keep
them safe, even seeming to die and resurrect in the process (Yuasa,
1969). This includes aspects of the Caregiver and Sage, but the Sage
generally defers physical fighting to the hero (Gaynor-Guthrie, 2023). The
Caregiver seems to be contextualized through the “Great Mother” archetype
(Main, 2023). The Christ, as Jung defines it, can contain both and yet still
more that applies to Gamera.
Jung notes that the Christ of religion and tradition does not have
a fitting Shadow and yet fights against evil, leading Jung to quote St.
Augustine, “Those things we call evil, then, are defects in good things….”
(Jung & Stoor, 2013 pp. 299-305). Whereas Gamera defends Earth and children
from Gyaos merely dutifully, Guiron does so sadistically. Importantly, whereas
Akio and Tom build a relationship with the Christ figure Gamera, as Jung
recommends, Flobella and Barbella’s use of technology as a shortcut for
Guiron’s control undermines their society’s strength in the aftermath of a
Gyaos attack (Yuasa, 1969). Gamera follows the boys to Tera because of his
overwhelming drive to save children, but the distance the Terans put between
themselves and Guiron downgrades his willingness to save them, turning him into
a soulless weapon. According to Wikizilla, the creature designer of
Guiron, Akira Inoue, said, “....when I put the head of a knife on a body I
created Guiron. It's not a living thing anymore, the idea comes from a
weapon….” (Wikizilla, 2022). This was a deliberate choice to reduce
Guiron physically to a weapon even when the being showed complex thought in
battle. It is significant that Gamera wins only when the children align with
his will and Guiron’s allies retreat. This essay will elaborate on Gamera
as a distinctly Jungian Christ; first, it is important to see how that
interpretation transforms the journeys of Akio and Tom with the villains.
Jungian Anima or Portal
Fantasy in Gamera vs Guiron - 820 words
Akio and Tom’s journey displays Jungian themes, as they start the
film as the characters most concerned with seeking unconscious truths about the
cosmos and gradually gain understanding about their role in their world by
mastering a shadow version of it. While the basic setup classifies Gamera
vs Guiron into portal fantasy, the film is a poor example of the associated
character arcs. Portal fantasy is essentially any story that emphasizes
bizarre creativity from the perspectives of young children discovering fantasy
worlds. Another word for a child’s fantasy world is paracosm (K. &
Swamy, 2021, pp. 28-29). Crucially, these stories function as a marriage
between reality and fantasy, brought on by a child protagonist’s boredom
(Tatar, 2020, pp 24-25, 27). Gamera vs Guiron is commonly vaguely
referred to as a fairy tale for reasons that fit portal fantasy. Coraline
by Neil Gaiman, the typical modern and contemporary portal fantasy novel, also
extends the genre to its ultimate implicit psychological stances on paracosm
(K. & Swamy, 2021, pp. 35).
Coraline’s paracosm is, in story, real but can also be considered
symbolic for the growth and maturity of a child during self play: wanting to
escape the world around her into a new one filled with magic, realizing the
imperfections of her paracosm, losing interest in it, and, finally, returning
to it in order to finish the story. Like all paracosm and most examples
of portal fantasy, Coraline’s Other World is a mixture of reality and fantasy;
in particular, the fantastical figures populating it are versions of the people
she knows in the real world (K. & Swamy, 2021, pp. 30-34, 32). The
expectation would then be for Gamera vs Guiron to follow these beats for
the journeys of Akio, Tom, and the people they find on Tera, and, lest it seem
an unfair comparison, Yuasa had already directed a horror film called The
Snake Girl and the Silver Haired Witch with similar tropes to those that
would eventually inform Coraline: ambiguously real fantasy and the
warping of surrounding people into monsters through the eyes of an intelligent
young girl (Miles).
The boys begin Gamera vs Guiron studying the stars through
Akio’s telescope, when they see a spaceship. Akio’s mother soon chastises
them for imagining a spaceship rather than studying, and Tom’s mother agrees,
casting them as stern characters, unlike Flobella and Barbella’s warm reaction
to the boy’s curiosity (Yuasa, 1969). However, Akio’s quirky neighbor,
policeman Kondo, does not have a Teran equivalent, nor does Akio’s sister
Tomoko, and Flobella and Barbella have an arc and dynamic more similar to Akio
and Tom than their mothers. Akio constantly orders around Tom, who obeys,
and Flobella does the same to Barbella, while the mothers are equals. Also, the
Terans plan to leave Tera, just as the boys left Earth. The film subverts
portal fantasy conventions in order to include another doubles pair. In
this case, the doubles are swapped in sex, which points back to Jung’s idea of
the anima/animus.
The anima (man’s inner woman) and animus (woman’s inner man)
generally comprise underlying personalities for the self based on the person’s
previous experiences with an opposite sex parent, and Jung writes that when
people remain unconscious to their world, the anima will be warped (Jung &
Stoor, 2013, pp. 104-109). Alfred Hitchcock’s Psycho is an
archetypal doubles film, and its doubles pair is the confused Norman becoming
his anima (Norma) in a deviant fashion (Barnett, 2007). Akio and Tom are
curious about the cosmos and Tera because they want to escape Earth; the Terans
are curious about Earth to escape there. Akio’s telescope is not precise
enough, so their animas act in imprecise and cruel ways: eating Akio’s brain
for his knowledge (Yuasa, 1969). According to Jung, “...when anima and
animus meet, the animus draws his sword of power, and the anima ejects her
poison of illusion and seduction” (2013, pp. 112). While Coraline crafted
a narrative through experiencing the paracosm and ultimately outsmarting the
Beldam, the only asset of Akio and Tom in their journey, other than Gamera, is
a cap gun that Tom has as a masculine symbol. The Terans deceive the boys
and are attractive (Madole,
2022).
Interestingly, neither the cap gun nor the trickery excel for the
pairs long term in their confrontation, even when they switch, with the boys
using trickery and the Terans using laser guns. This is because the anima
and animus are complementary, and the self must accept both the logical male
traits and the emotional female traits in order to achieve awareness (Jung
& Stoor, 2013, pp. 113). To win, Akio and Tom have to exemplify both
halves, containing the emotional Tom and logical Akio and align the technology
of Tera to Gamera’s will, controlling a rocket missile for Gamera to use against
Guiron. The Terans do not assimilate Earth and divide, leaving Flobella at the
mercy of an incidental missile collision, no longer in control of
Tera.
Gamera vs Guiron portrays its worlds and the struggle of using technology to try
to understand or master them, and this is important both to Jung and portal
fantasy. Some of the historical hallmarks of portal fantasy are odd
vehicles (the portal itself), references to sweets, magic, and an implicit
disdain for Enlightenment scientific ideals and technology. One of the
earliest influences on the genre E.T.A. Hoffmann used the concept of whimsical
fancies of bored children to create magical aesthetics and explore debunked
magical thinking (Tatar, 2020, pp. 31-32, 26-27, 36).
The Terans tempt Akio and Tom with donuts, and the overreliance of
the Terans and human scientists on modern technology prevent them from
understanding their worlds. However, the boys’ eventual mastery over Tera and return
home hinges on the use of technology; crucially, the portal vehicle is not
magical at all but a mere spaceship. The aesthetic of Tera is not magical
but technological (Yuasa, 1969). According to Jung, “technology is
neutral…neither good nor bad,” with the danger being a misplaced sense of
control over the world, with the lack of consciousness in operating the
technology inevitably leading to destruction (Brien, 2013). The film is closer
to this because the use of technology is from honest efforts to understand the
cosmos or improve life, from Akio’s telescope to the Earthbound scientists
studying space and even the Teran innovations, and the positive characters
accept Akio and Tom’s conscious explanation.
Under the purview of portal fantasy, the Teran Space Gyaos are
technically an “Other Gyaos” but not ones that say anything about the nature of
the boys’ paracosm. Interestingly, the origin of Space Gyaos in this film
is that they were a created species on Tera that wreaked havoc on their creators
(Yuasa, 1969). The Terans’ technological advancement led to their
destruction. There is a component of childlike randomness in the film’s
explanation, that it was a computer malfunction that generated uncontrollable
monsters, but the film constantly reiterates that Akio’s idea of a superior
world would lack wars and traffic accidents, and Tera shows him that world with
its teleportation machines and superior technology. It is warped because
technology does not bring Jungian awareness. That superior technology can
malfunction to create monsters, necessitating the creation of missiles and
other monsters (Yuasa, 1969).
Answer to Job in Gamera
vs Guiron - 427 words
Outside of the mere allusion, appointing Gamera as Christ requires
more specific character beats to fit as a Jungian archetype. Jung wrote
exhaustively, and to some degree uncomfortably and unwillingly, about how the
god-image could be both good and evil particularly in the Book of Job
(Woolfson, 2009, pp. 127-128). This is, evidently, because of Jung’s
complicated emotions toward Christianity and God as a whole following the loss
of faith of his father Paul Jung (Woolfson, 2009, pp. 124, 134). In the
Book of Job, God tested Job’s faithfulness with a series of horrible trials,
and Job endured it (Jung & Stoor, 2013, pp. 309-320). While Jung
emphasized the importance of both positive masculine and feminine influences
(syzygy of anima and animus) and the risks of lacking either, it greatly
disturbed Jung to realize that God lacked the caring feminine traits until
after Job’s story. Suffice it to say, this goes against everything else
in Jung’s psychology about man’s need to align with God’s will to find
enlightenment if God was “unconscious” and “monstrous” (Woolfson, 2009, pp.
135, 138, 134). Eventually, Jung concluded that Job showing greater
goodness than God is what inspired God to become Christ (Jung & Stoor,
2013, pp. 309).
Inexplicably, this idea has a parallel in Gamera vs Guiron;
in order to learn more about the Gyaos-slaying Gamera, the Terans
technologically extract Akio’s memories to recapitulate the previous films,
including showing Gamera’s first act of heroism (Yuasa, 1969). The montage
briefly shows Gamera’s journey from destroying a lighthouse and catching a
child to defending the same child from Gyaos to finally defending all children
from the extraterrestrial squid Viras. This covers Gamera’s arc well; he was an
attacking monster that saved a child, and that event inspired Gamera to be “The
Friend to All Children” (Yuasa, 1969). In a revisionist sense, this
montage is the truest version up to that point in the series of those past
events, and its deviations correspond to Jung. It is not as precise as
Jung’s Answer to Job, because Yuasa had a different agenda.
Yuasa campaigned seriously to include the lighthouse scene and
follow it through to its natural conclusions in subsequent entries (Cynical
Justin, 2022). An interview clarified why this was so important to Yuasa;
he briefly filmed at a home for abandoned children, saw their sadness and
appointed Gamera as a friend to all children for them (Buttgereit,
2002).
Later creatives on the franchise would make the comparison even
less subtle, but this is also the first film where Gamera undergoes a cycle of
death and rebirth.
Limitations - 162 words
Jung’s writings and Yuasa’s film have different goals and will,
consequently, not line up in every detail. First, all this aforementioned
Jungian subtext is exclusive to this movie and the presentation of those stock
footage scenes. Secondly, as a consequence to Jungian unconsciousness plaguing
the boys’ mothers, they do not encompass many of Jung’s Mother Archetype
tropes; they are neither great sources of wisdom, nor terrible, seductive
objects (Jung, 1968 pp. 81-84). Finally, this essay cannot present any evidence
that Yuasa was familiar with Jung or held any Christian beliefs. Yuasa’s
description of his own beliefs in his works extends more to finding humanity in
giant creatures than finding divinity in man (Buttgereit, 2002). Also, as
aforementioned, Yuasa directed The Snake Girl and the Silver Haired Witch,
which features both Christianity and Nietzsche subtext in its monsters
(Wilkins, 2022). However, that film was based on a large body of work
from Kazuo Umezu, who has his own associated tropes and views (Miles).
Conclusion - 125 words
In conclusion, this essay contrasted interpretations of the film
Gamera vs Guiron in order to argue that it predominantly upheld Jungian
conventions, even deviating from the parameters of portal fantasy in order to
do so. The portrayal of Gamera and Guiron as a Christ/Shadow pair, the
boys and villains along the parameters of animus/anima development, the
uniquely Jungian stance on technology and rough depiction of the Answer to Job outweighed
the alternative explanations that portal fantasy would provide. Based on
this research, there are similarities between the outlooks of Yuasa and Jung,
and further analysis through this lens could help to better understand Yuasa’s
intent on his filmography. Further cursory research suggests potential
commonalities in both of their views on animals and children.
References
Barnett, V. L. (2007). Dualling for judy: the concept of the
double in the films of kim novak. Film History, 19(1), 86+. https://link.gale.com/apps/doc/A160592787/PPFA?u=ogde72764&sid=bookmark-PPFA&xid=544229b0
Brien, D. E. (2013, October 27). The star in man:
jung and technology. Jungpage. https://jungpage.org/learn/articles/technology-and-environment/681-the-star-in-man-jung-and-technology
Cynical Justin. (2022, August 26). The history
and evolution of gamera [Video]. YouTube. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qfArMhrfvAA
Draper, M. (2023, August, 2). GAMERA: The
heisei series retrospective - The greatest kaiju movies ever made [Video].
YouTube. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PnAh4uzxxOY
Draper, M. (2023, May 17). GAMERA: The showa
era retrospective - The rise & fall of a cult kaiju icon [Video].
YouTube. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0jeTGqdW1-k
Gaynor-Guthrie, G. (2023, March 9). The sage archetype: a guide. Literature
and Latte. https://www.literatureandlatte.com/blog/the-sage-archetype-a-guide-literature-latte-1#:~:text=What%20is%20a%20sage%20archetype,the%20world%20and%20its%20mysteries.
Jung, C. G. (1968). Collected works of c. g. Jung Jung, Vol. 9, Part 1. 2nd ed., Princeton University
Press (pp. 81-84).
JUNG, C. G. (2012). 27 june 1934. In JAMES L. JARRETT (Ed.), Nietzsche's
"zarathustra" (pp. 129). Princeton University Press.
Jung, C. G., &
Storr, A. (2013). The essential jung (Paperback reissue, with a new
foreword by John Beebe. ed.). Princeton University Press
K., K., & Swamy, S. K. (2021). Through the
portals of the mind: A paracosmic study of neil gaiman’s coraline. Fafnir, 8(2),
28-37
Madole, D. (host). DaikaijuTony. & Barry, S.
& Derek. & Blount, C. (panelists). (2022, January 15). TokuTitanCast
#17 Ranking every gamera movie! In TokuTitanCast. YouTube. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fttH5MNgCR8
Main, P. (2023). Carl jung’s archetypes. In P.
Main (Ed.) Cognitive Development https://www.structural-learning.com/post/carl-jungs-archetypes
Miles, S. (N.A. September, 26). [Film Review]
Snake girl and the silver haired witch (1968). Ghouls Magazine. https://www.ghoulsmagazine.com/articles/snake-girl-and-the-silver-haired-witch-1968-horror-film-review
Tatar, M. (2020). Inventing portal fantasies: E.
T. A. hoffmann's the nutcracker and the mouse king. Marvels & Tales, 34(1),
24-37. https://doi.org/10.13110/marvelstales.34.1.0024
Wilkins, B. (2022, January 7). Review: yuasa noriaki’s the snake
girl and the silver haired witch on arrow blu-ray. Slant. https://www.slantmagazine.com/dvd/the-snake-girl-and-the-silver-haired-witch-blu-ray-review-yuasa-noriaki-arrow/
Woodside, A.G., & Sood, S. C. (2016). Storytelling-case
archetype decoding and assignment manual (SCADAM) (2st ed.). Emerald
Publishing Limited. https://doi.org/10.1108/S1871-3173201611
Woolfson, T. (2009). The book of job revisited. The
International Journal of Jungian Studies, 1(2), 123-143. https://doi.org/10.1080/19409050903109330
Wurdeman, A. (2022, February 15). The innocent archetype -
everything you need to know. Dabblewriter. https://www.dabblewriter.com/articles/the-innocent-archetype
Yuasa, N. (1969). ガメラ対大悪獣ギロン, Gamera tai daiakujū
giron [gamera vs. giant evil beast guiron]. Shout Factory!; Mill Creek
Entertainment; Arrow Video; American International Pictures (AIP); Daiei Film
Yuasa, N. (Director). (2021). Gamera: the showa era collection
gamera vs viras/gamera vs guiron [Film; BluRay with special features,
specifically the interview taken from Die Monsterinsel of Yuasa with
Jorg Buttgereit on August 10, 2002]. Arrow Video
Yuasa, N. (Director). (2021). Gamera: the showa era collection
gamera vs viras/gamera vs guiron [Film; BluRay with special features,
specifically David Kalat’s commentary track of Gamera vs Guiron].
Arrow Video
(2022, September). Guiron. Wikizilla. https://wikizilla.org/w/index.php?title=Guiron&oldid=170910
To read a review of Gamera versus Guiron, go here.
